• Hi,
  • MessageInbox ()
  • Account
  • Logout
  • Login
  • Sign up
Spongefish

Dating Tech Food Home Humor Travel Style

Where did the idea of copyrights come from?

404 views  views

Vote_up(6)
Vote_up(6)
Vote_down(0)
Vote_down(0)
StumbleUpon digg Reddit del.icio.us

Highlights

  • Copyrights arose in the 18th century
  • Since then, there's been a debate over "Intellectual property" vs. sharing deas
  • SpongeFish strikes a balance
The printing press was invented in 1440 by Gutenberg. The first law 
about intellectual property was written in the English Statute of Anne in 
1710. (The word copyright itself didn't appear until 1767 in 
Blackstone's Commentary on  the Book of Laws.)  So why did it take three  
centures for the idea of copyright to  arise? One reason is that it took that long 
for literacy to spread and grow enough for printing lots of books and 
sellng them to become a good business proposition. The change was gradual, 
but it  accelerated in the late 1700s with the quickening rise of commerce and 
the middle classes. 
 
This was one of those cultural feedback loops: commerce raised general 
prosperity,  which spread literacy, which made book publishing good 
business, which in turn fueled commerce and literacy, and so on. 
The idea of copyrighting marked a dramatic moment in history of our 
culture: when a book was no longer just a means to broadcast ideas, 
but was also considered a piece of property that could be owned 
and bought and sold. The reaction among some thinkers was strong:

"No, no, it is too obvious that the concept of intellectual property is useless. My property is exclusively mine; I must be able to dispose of it and retrieve it unconditionally. Let someone explain to me how that is possible with ideas. Just let someone try taking back the ideas he has originated once they have been communicated so that they are, as before, nowhere to be found. All the money in the world could not make that possible."

-- Christian Sigmund Krause, 1783 

Rare manuscript from before copyrights
Click here to zoom.
Illuminated book from before the era of copyrights
Like many people who use the internet sites like SpongeFish to share their ideas, 
music, words, images, videos and blogs today, the fellow who wrote this - Christian 
Sigmund Krause - thought the idea of owning the words and ideas expressed in books 
was ludicrous.   Krause was protesting the idea of intellectual property in general. 
He was particularly offended by the idea that a book was a mere thing 
that someone owned and that couldn't be copied and shared or else you 
could be punished by law.
 
Krause's salvo was just the beginning of the war between those who want 
information to be free and those who want artists and authors and the 
publishers and companies that  broadcast them to get the fair share of the 
value they produce.  On one side is the enormous worldwide black 
[ or maybe just "grey"]  market for ripping, sharing, bitstreaming, 
mashing up and copying music,  videos, images and texts.
 
On the other side are the huge publishing and media companies and 
the RIAA. They are in a constant struggle to lock up and protect digital content.
 
On the one side, too, are the millions of contributors to Wikipedia 
who generously, and anonymously, contribute their knowledge to 
maintain the world's largest and growing open encyclopedia. On the 
other, are equally noble and altruistic artists, musicians and 
authors who eke out meagre livings in the grips of their talents and 
their overwhelming compulsion to create. They deserve to be recognized 
and rewarded for their expression. Many struggle to make that living. 
Most never do.
 
In between is SpongeFish, which someone called "the MySpace for the Mind,"
where unlike Wikipedia, authors and artists  are recognized for what they know, 
but at the same time get the satisfaction of sharing and broadcasting and seeing 
their expressions reach their audience. 

Did you like this?

Vote_up(6)
Vote_up(6)
Vote_down(0)
Vote_down(0)
StumbleUpon digg Reddit del.icio.us

Tags: content sharing, copyright, free information, hjjhj, information wants to be free, intellectual property first..., internet, riaa, ripping music, spongefish, technology

Spinner
  • Published Sep. 8, 2007
  • EditEdit
  • MessageEmail This
  • Favorite_removeStop Following This
    Favorite_addFollow This
  • Flag_removeRemove Flag
    Flag_addFlag as Inappropriate

You Might Like These Too...

Edit
Remove
Thumbnail

Try It Yourself Hacks!

297 views

Dillonp23 (Level 1)

Edit
Remove
Thumbnail

WELCOME TO THE WORLD OF MOVIE REVIEWS

10 views

EagleChat (Level 3)

Edit
Remove
Thumbnail

You've Got Mail... A few tips on Email

119 views

Frank (Level 4)

Edit
Remove
Thumbnail

how to disable error reporting

9 views

gilltut (Level 3)

See More »

Leave a Comment

Let me know when anyone comments
Please Wait Spinner
  1. Asparagas

    Stewie at 1:30am on Sep. 10, 2007

    10 months ago

    Delete

    Enjoyed your observation that once "reading" got traction, people could sell books. Hasn't the Internet evolved the same way? Doesn't pirating also affects the artists since they earn royalties based on sales? This puts them on the same side as the publishers and media companies. Reply...

    Let me know when anyone comments
    Please Wait Spinner
    1. David head shot

      David at 2:12pm on Sep. 10, 2007

      Delete

      Agreed, Stewie. The Internet evolved the same way books did. The history of radio and tv show the same pattern: first its free and wide open, and then as it becomes a mass market medium, it becomes a channel for commerce.

      I also agree with your second point: that authors and artists who *do* get published should be on the side of the recording and media companies. But the Internet gives a channel for all those - 90%++ - who never get published, but who have the deep urge to share and be recognized. By providing a wide-open and popular stage for their work, SpongeFish and other sites give those artists another way to get to their audience, and maybe, down the road, even profit from it.

      Furthermore, the major channels - tv, pubishing, record labels, movie studios - serve a very narrow highly filtered, though undoubtedly popular, spectrum of taste. The Internet enables the entire spectrum - the Long Tail - of talents to be broadcast and possibly satisfy the whole spectrum of tastes, including some we haven't recognized yet.

      So the Internet, and channels like SpongeFish, gives us a way out of the PUBLISHING OR PIRACY dilemma.
      Reply...

      Let me know when anyone comments
      Please Wait Spinner

About the Author

David head shot

David (Level 6)

5,610 coins

MessageMessage Me

Favorite_removeStop Following Me

Favorite_addFollow Me

Create_now
Join_free

Want Something Different?

Edit
Remove
Flickr

100 Burning Questions

3,446 views

lb (Level 6)

Edit
Remove
Thumbnail

Google Hacks Volume III

4,818 views

Halla (Level 5)

Edit
Remove
How_to_make_a_bb_gun

Most Powerful BB Gun Ever

2,469 views

RazorG606 (Level 6)

See More »

You Might Like These Too...

Edit
Remove
Thumbnail

Vista App: How to customize your logon screen

15 views

KidGuru (Level 5)

Edit
Remove
Copyofsilentbob

100 Signs Your Internet Girlfriend is Really a Guy Messing With You

1,181 views

Jason (Level 7)

Edit
Remove
Thumbnail

My New Tech-World Podcasts Ep.1!

20 views

KidGuru (Level 5)

See More »
  • About
  • FAQ
  • Contact
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Feedback

Copyright 2008 SpongeFish, Inc.